The Islamic WorldviewWorld ReligionsSecular EthicsThe Christian WorldviewThe Jewish WorldviewGeneral KnowledgeAdmin
The Islamic Worldview

Why does Allah say signs and not facts, in Qur'an?

Sign in to ask a follow-up question or comment.

Conclusion

The Qur'an calls creation "signs" (ayat) because, in these sources, the point of creation is what it indicates. Each thing is a marker ('alamah) pointing to Allah's existence, oneness, knowledge and power, and to fear of His might. A sign also needs someone to read it: the verses address it to "people who reflect", "have understanding" or "believe", and they note that others see the same sign and turn away.

Reflection & guidance

  1. Meaning

    An ayah (sign) is something that points beyond itself to Allah. Ibn Kathir explains that the "people of understanding" are sound minds that "contemplate about the true reality of things". Those who pass by the signs and turn away from them are compared to the deaf and mute. Q1T1

  2. Guidance from the Qur'an

    The verses repeatedly say the signs are "for a people who reflect", whether they are the subjugation of the heavens and earth or the love Allah places between spouses. The reader is called to reflect, not only to note what is there. Q11Q12

  3. Guidance from the Sunnah

    When the Prophet named the sun and moon as signs, he linked seeing them to fear of Allah and to prayer. A sign is meant to move the heart to worship. H8H3

  4. Guidance from the scholars

    Tafsir Mazhari, as quoted in Maarif-ul-Quran, holds that the muqinin (those with certain faith) keep pondering the signs on earth and in themselves, and this increases their belief. Ibn Hajar adds that signs also serve as a warning. T5C2

Sources

Qur'an & Tafsir

Summary

The Qur'an presents the universe and the human self as ayat (signs) that point to Allah and testify to Him. The tafsir explains that they show His existence, knowledge, power and oneness. A sign only does its work for someone who receives it: some people see one and turn away. Q2T2Q8

Key points

  • Mufti Muhammad Shafi explains that the signs in the afaq (horizons, the whole universe) and in people's own selves bear witness "not only to the existence of Allah" but also to His knowledge, His authority and His being One. T2
  • The future tense of "We will show them" means, on his reading, that Allah keeps showing new signs until the Day of Judgment, so the set of signs is never closed. T2
  • The same sign can be dismissed: some people see a sign and call it "transient magic". Q8

References

  • Q2Fussilat 41:53 · Explained in Detail
  • Q8Al-Qamar 54:2 · The Moon
  • T2Maarif-ul-Quran on 41:53

Sunnah

Summary

The Prophet called the sun and moon "two signs amongst the signs of Allah". In these narrations, seeing a sign calls for a response: through them Allah makes His servants fear Him, and the believers are told to pray when they see an eclipse. H8H3

Key points

  • Eclipses are not caused by anyone's death or birth. As signs, they point to Allah, not to human events. H8
  • The response the Prophet taught on seeing a sign is to pray. This hadith is in Sahih al-Bukhari. H3

References

  • H3Sahih al Bukhari 1057 · Eclipses
    Authenticity
    • Sahih — the whole collection is accepted as authentic (Sahih al-Bukhari)
  • H8Sahih al Bukhari 1048 · Eclipses
    Authenticity
    • Sahih — the whole collection is accepted as authentic (Sahih al-Bukhari)

Hadith Commentaries

Summary

Ibn Hajar explains ayatan (two signs) as 'alamatan (two markers or indicators). They point to Allah's oneness and immense power, or serve to make His servants fear His might. In support he quotes the verse "We send not the signs except to make [people] fear". C2

Key points

  • Al-Sindi notes that the sun eclipsed on the day the Prophet's son Ibrahim died. People assumed the death caused it, and the Prophet corrected them: a sign points to its Maker, not to the events of people's lives. C1

References

  • C1Hashiyat al-Sindi on al-Nasa'i on Sunan an-Nasa'i 1459 · al-Sindi, vol. 3 p. 123
  • C2Fath al-Bari on Sahih al-Bukhari 1041 · Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, vol. 2 p. 527

Expert Opinions

Summary

Expert Opinions report Dr. Zakir Naik's approach, which treats the Qur'an not as a science textbook but as a book of "signs" pointing to its Author. On this view, statements that match later discoveries serve as signs, not as a list of facts. N1

Key points

  • In this approach, the signs are used to lead someone who already accepts there is a "creator" to recognise that the creator is Allah. N1

References

  • N1Existence of God · Belief
Sign in to ask a follow-up question or comment.

Comments

Loading…

Sign in to comment.